PART VI - Mechanisms of Grain-Boundary Grooving in Chromium, Molybdenum, Tungsten, Cr-35Re, Mo-33Re, and W-25Re

Grain-boundary gvoocing was studied irz chronziu?n. molybdenum, tungsten, and the solid-solution alloys, Cr-35Re. Mo-33Re, and W-25Re at 0.6 to 0.9 of the absolute liquidus temperature under an inevt atmosphere , foveign nzetal zlapor, and liquid metal. The controlling mechanism of matter transport was deduced frolr groove size and shape. kinetics of growth, and cotnparisoz with theoretical relatiotzships derived by Mullins. Grooves in chowzizon formed prittzarily by volume diffusion tkrongk kelium or argon at 1 atm pressure and by e1)apovation-condensatiotz in a static vacuum. Groozles in the other nzetals and alloys forrned priniarily by sirface diffusion, the coefficients of which were calculated. Carbon was found to decrease the acti7:ation energy for surface diffusion on molybdenun. Sitrface diffusizities weve sinzilav for iWo-0.0ZC and Mo-33Re. The presence of about 1 -?nm pressure of silver or tin vapor did not affect the neckanis)n of grooz;e formation. In liquid titz or silz:er, pain bolindary gvooves formed by zolume diffusion in the liquid. BASED on theories of ullins," the mechanisms of grain-boundary grooving have been determined for low-melting metals such as copper in an inert atmospheres or in liquid lead.4 The purpose of this investigation was to study grain-boundary grooving in the refractory Group VI-A metals, chromium, molybdenum, and tungsten, and the bcc solid-solution alloys, r-35e, 0-33e,= and -25e,' at 0.6 to 0.9 of included to see whether Mullins' theories were applicable to them as well. EXPERIMENTAL WORK The materials chromium, molybdenum, tungsten, Cr-35Re, Mo-33Re, and W-25Re were in the form of 0.050-cm-thick sheet assaying 99.98 pct or better. The nominal carbon level was generally 30 ppm. The oxygen + nitrogen + hydrogen content was -50 ppm. Mo-33Re and W-25Re were prepared by powder-metallurgy methods and supplied by Chase Brass and Copper Co. The remaining materials were arc-cast. Chromium and Cr-35Re were prepared at Battelle by arc melting, extruding, swaging, and rolling. Mo-0.003C was supplied by Climax Molybdenum Co., and Mo-0.02C and tungsten by Universal Cyclops Corp. As a source of liquid metals, tin and silver granules assaying 99.98 pct were used. Spectrographic analyses indicated the presence of -100 ppm each of iron and silicon. Vacuum melting reduced the combined gas content to c5 ppm (2.60,, 0.9N2, 0.4H2 in tin and l.602, 0.7N2, and c0.04H2 in silver). Specimens were prepared for grain-boundary grooving. Coupons 0.5 by 1.5 cm with a small hole in one end, or substrates 1.5 by 1.5 cm, were cut from sheet. The specimens were annealed in containers of the same material to provide a vapor-solid equilibrium as well as to protect them from gaseous impurities. Outgassing was done at 2 x 10"5 mm for 15 to 30 min at 1150°C for chromium and Cr-35Re, 1750°C for molybdenum and Mo-33Re, and 2600°C for tungsten and W-25Re. Then recrystallization to a stable grain size of about 0.5 mm was accomplished by annealing at least 1 hr at 1600°C for chromium, 1800°C for Cr-35Re, 2350°C for molybdenum, and 2300°C for Mo-33Re in a rhenium-element resistance furnace under 1 atm of static argon or helium. The atmosphere was gettered by tantalum radiation shielding. Tungsten and