A new approach to assessing energy efficiency, grindability and HPGR technology by comminution research

"Comminution not only is the major energy cost in mineral processing but it also can limit the grade of ores that can economically be processed. Rittinger first postulated that the energy for comminution is proportional to the new surface produced. Because most of the strain energy needed to initiate and propagate cracks in particles cannot be recovered, researchers reported woefully low comminution efficiencies. Recognizing this, Schoenert proposed that the baseline for assessing comminution efficiency should be the mechanical energy needed to break single particles. After extensive single-particle studies, Schoenert turned to comminuting beds of particle in piston dies. Finding particle-bed comminution to be energy efficient, he had the brilliant conception of making the process continuous, namely his invention of the choke-fed high-pressure roll mill (HPGR). Practical comminution involves masses of particles, which can lead to energy efficiencies far less than that of single-particle breakage. A three-way classification of grinding modes in terms of the mobility of the particle mass provides the necessary insight into the low efficiency of different comminution machines: namely, single-particle breakage, confined particle-bed grinding (HPGR), and loose-bed grinding (ball mill). Examples are given for determining and comparing comminution efficiencies. The size distribution of comminuted products become self-similar, and a single parameter, the median size, can be used to quantify the extent of comminution. The reduction ratio, expressed in terms of the mean size of the feed and product, varies linearly with expended energy and the slope of such plots is a measure of the grindability of the mineral. This approach clearly gives the order of energy efficiency as single-particle > particle-bed > loose-bed comminution. HPGRs are more efficient at low reduction ratios but lose that advantage at higher reduction ratios. Extensive hybrid grinding experiments carried out with our instrumented ball mill and HPGR showed significant energy savings by first comminuting the material in the HPGR and followed by the ball mill. At Cerro Verde an industrial-scale hybrid HPGR/ball mill system is reported to have a 13 percent energy savings over a SAG mill/ball mill system."