Comparison of Pillar Strengths Calculated Using Empirical Equations and Finite Elements

de Andrade Lima, Aarao
Organization: International Conference on Ground Control in Mining
Pages: 8
Publication Date: Jan 1, 1997
Mechanical properties typical of coal are used in the comparisons of pillar strengths based on finite elements and the empirical equations of Holland-Gaddy, Salamon-Munro, Obert¬Duvall, and Bieniawski-PSU. A correlation among the strength parameters which are employed in the empirical equations, in Mohr-Coulomb and Hoek-Brown failure criteria is established. Emphasis is given to the important distinction between the mechanical properties of small rock specimens and those related to the rock mass. An elastoplastic version of Hoek-Brown criteria has been developed and implemented in a finite elements code. The strengths calculated using the empirical equations showed a good agreement when the ratio width by height of the pillars varied from I to 8, except for Holland-Gaddy equation which exhibited lower values. Under the hypothesis of associative perfect elastoplasticity used, pillar strength calculated using Mohr¬Coulomb yield criterion became excessively high for all the models having a pillar width by height ratio above 2. The finite elements solution based on Hoek-Brown criterion predicted strengths around fifty percent larger than Bieniawski-PSU equation when the pillars width by height ration varied from 3 to 8, showing good agreement below that range. It has been concluded that, under the hypothesis of percfect plasticity, stress analysis techniques may overestimate the strength of rock structures subjected to high confining stresses.
Full Article Download:
(1898 kb)


Additional chapters/articles from the SME-ICGCM book 16th International Conference on Ground Control in Mining (ICGCM)

Longwall Mining-Through the Backfilled In-Panel Entries at C
Performance of Various Standing and Cribless Tailgate Suppor
Measurement of Effects of Interaction and Influence on Mine
Effects of Longwall Mining on Streamflow in the Pittsburgh S
Longwall Surface Subsidence Prediction Through Numerical Mod
Long-term Subsidence Over Longwall Chain Pillar Systems and
Subsidence Prediction Influence Assessment and Damage Contro
Formation of Face Headings Using Stress Relief at Asfordby M
Significant Weighting Events on the Longwalls in the Phalen
Full-face Pressure Monitoring in Medium-Weak Roof Condition
Research on the Interaction Between Roof Strata and Shield S
Roof Instability of Longwall Face at Ikeshima Colliery
Gob Canopy Roof Support for Difficult Natural Conditions
Yielding Cement Roof Supports for Longwall Mining
Management of the Dynamic Phenomena of Rock Pressure in Unde
Continuing Development of Innovative Cable Support Systems
Extending the Limits of Strata Bolting by the Use of Flexibl
Implementation and Evaluation of Roof Bolting in MICARE Mine
New Methods and Technologies of Roofbolting in Australia Coa
New Design Criteria for Roof Bolt Systems
Control Mechanism of a Tensioned Bolt System in the Laminate
A Study of the Performance of Glass Fibre Rock Reinforcement
A Method for the Selection of Rock Support Based on Bolt Loa
Strategies for the Application of Rockbolting Technology to
A Troubleshooting Guide for Roof Support Systems
A Statistical Overview of Retreat Mining of Coal Pillars in
Full-Scale Performance Evaluation of Mobile Roof Supports
Effect of the Interchamber Pi Yield on the Surface Strains i
Salt Pillar Design Equation
Case Study of Conditions Observed During the Removal of a Hi
Case Study of the Effect of Stratigraphic Location on Roof S
Ground Control and the Inundation of the Retsof Mine
Weatherability Test of Rocks for Underground Mines
Shear Strength Characteristics of Soft Rock Joints Based on
Comparison of Pillar Strengths Calculated Using Empirical Eq
Effects of In-seam and Near-seam Conditions and Asymmetric P
Ground Control Worker Safety During Extended Cut Mining
Analysis of Extensometer Data from a Room Widening Experimen
Airbag Support for Ground Control in Thin Seam Coal Mining
Development of a Statistical-Analytical Approach for Assessi
Ground Control Criteria for Coal Reserve Optimization in Mul
Calcium Aluminate Kiders in Hard Rock and Coal Mining
Simplified Pre-and Post-Processing Technique for Performing